what is consciousness?

October 15, 2022 on Eric Bower's blog

In a past life I was studying neuroscience at my university. I’ve had just enough experience and training to wade in dangerous waters on this topic. Having said that, consciousness was essentially taboo in my undergraduate studies. “The only people working on consciousness are people with tenure and in later stages of their career.” The implication being it’s a dead end and purely for the enjoyment of the professor.

I stumbled upon a HN article where someone asked the following:

How is consciousness possible?

There are some “business requirements” as far as I know. We need:

You need space and time because thinking is a verb. Action is required which needs the passage of time.

You need memory in order to link past events with current ones. I’m not strictly talking about memory from earlier in the year or day, but also working memory from what you perceived a second ago. Continuity seems essential.

Inputs are require because we need a data stream to grapple onto and spark brain activity. The brain can obviously cause its own activity as well.

After that it’s just a recursive ETL function via the thalamo-cortical loop[1]. The “self” doesn’t necessarily need to live in this loop, but it needs access to the data stream. Inputs trigger neurons/glial that recall past events which all get fed into a bunch of decision making models that spits out new thoughts or decisions which cause us to act. The loop is happening so quickly and chaotically that coupled with randomness, short term and long term memory … you’ve essentially got a system to explain creativity and “free will”.

I love the “Allowed to Think” series on youtube. There’s a great clip with John Searle who demystifies consciousness. In the video[2], he explains that really, consciousness is just an emergent property of nervous systems.

It doesn’t seem nearly as magical through this lens but that’s what makes it so convincing to me. Consciousness is not special, we just think it is because we are inescapably biased.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cortico-basal_ganglia-thalamo-cortical_loop#Research [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0XTDLq34M18


Articles from blogs I read

Generated by openring

How to help improve SourceHut's design

SourceHut is a software development forge and it is designed with the software engineer’s needs first and foremost. The design prioritizes things like page speed, minimal distractions, and information-forward layouts. It does not prioritize aesthetics, and p…

via Blogs on Sourcehut October 13, 2022

In praise of ffmpeg

My last “In praise of” article covered qemu, a project founded by Fabrice Bellard, and today I want to take a look at another work by Bellard: ffmpeg. Bellard has a knack for building high-quality software which solves a problem so well that every other solu…

via Drew DeVault's blog October 12, 2022

Site Update: HLS support

Hi blog readers! It's time for a regular update on stuff I've gained expertise in frantically googled and hacked together so I can put it in front of your faces. I use YouTube as a video hosting service because it's largely predictable and it'…

via Xe's Blog October 11, 2022